v0.3 — Visual Edition | V1 Heat B | Field Guide

V1 Heat B: First-Pass Field Guide

Three AI models responded to the same brief. These are their first-pass diagrams, before critique, constraint, or revision. Review each one, then vote.

Poll question: Which first-pass diagram communicates the ROY argument most clearly at first glance?

The poll runs on LinkedIn. Follow OverKill Hill P³™ on LinkedIn to participate when each heat goes live.

Copilot V1

Presentation-ready system thinking. Strong architecture, clear phases, deliverable feel.

--- config: theme: neutral fontFamily: Aptos, Segoe UI, Inter, Arial, sans-serif themeVariables: primaryColor: '#EAF2FF' primaryTextColor: '#14213D' primaryBorderColor: '#325DCC' lineColor: '#64748B' secondaryColor: '#FFF7E8' tertiaryColor: '#EEFDF3' fontFamily: Aptos, Segoe UI, Inter, Arial, sans-serif look: neo --- flowchart TB subgraph I1["Ideation / wording"] direction TD B["Brain-dump angles"] A["Define the clarity we are buying"] C["Draft ugly first post"] D{"Hook lands?"} E["Ask LLM for Mermaid skeleton"] end subgraph I2["Modeling / diagramming"] direction TD F["Render V1 🧭"] G{"Too tidy / too fake?"} H["Add forks, loops, dead ends"] I["Trim labels · reorder flow · kill clutter ✂️"] J["Diagram earns its space"] end subgraph I3["Post assembly / shipping"] direction TD P["Write around diagram:\nHook · thesis · proof · CTA"] Q{"Clear and scannable?"} R["Ship post + code + image set 🚀"] W["Watch comments for confusion"] end S(("Spark ✨")) --> T["👀 Notice text fatigue"] T --> U{"Text alone enough?"} U -- Yes --> P0["Stay in prose"] U -- No --> A A --> B B --> C C --> D D -- No --> B D -- Yes --> E E --> F F --> G G -- Yes --> H H --> I I --> F G -- No --> J J --> P P --> Q Q -- No --> I Q -- Yes --> R R --> W W -. feedback loop .-> B B:::core A:::core C:::draft D:::gate E:::core F:::draft G:::gate H:::risk I:::risk J:::publish P:::core Q:::gate R:::publish W:::low S:::spark T:::core U:::gate P0:::low classDef spark fill:#FFF4CC,stroke:#D6A700,color:#4A3B00,stroke-width:2.5px classDef core fill:#EAF2FF,stroke:#325DCC,color:#102A43,stroke-width:1.6px classDef draft fill:#F3F4F6,stroke:#6B7280,color:#334155,stroke-width:1.4px,stroke-dasharray: 5 3 classDef gate fill:#F3E8FF,stroke:#7C3AED,color:#3B0764,stroke-width:2px classDef risk fill:#FFF1F2,stroke:#DC2626,color:#7F1D1D,stroke-width:1.8px classDef publish fill:#ECFDF5,stroke:#059669,color:#064E3B,stroke-width:2.2px classDef low fill:#F8FAFC,stroke:#94A3B8,color:#64748B,stroke-width:1.2px,stroke-dasharray: 3 3 linkStyle 0 stroke:#325DCC,stroke-width:2.4px,fill:none linkStyle 3 stroke:#325DCC,stroke-width:2.2px,fill:none linkStyle 8 stroke:#DC2626,stroke-width:2px,stroke-dasharray: 6 4,fill:none linkStyle 12 stroke:#DC2626,stroke-width:2.2px,fill:none linkStyle 13 stroke:#DC2626,stroke-width:2.2px,stroke-dasharray: 6 4,fill:none linkStyle 14 stroke:#059669,stroke-width:2.8px,fill:none linkStyle 17 stroke:#DC2626,stroke-width:2.2px,stroke-dasharray: 6 4,fill:none linkStyle 18 stroke:#059669,stroke-width:2.8px,fill:none linkStyle 20 stroke:#7C3AED,stroke-width:2px,stroke-dasharray: 2 4,fill:none

Notion V1

Quietly effective. Clean lanes, minimalist, setup/compression/shipping separation.

--- config: theme: neutral look: neo --- flowchart LR subgraph P["Prose - setup"] A["Spark: confusion costs time 💥"] B["Audience + decision"] C["Claim draft"] D["ROY check: Return on Your Words"] end subgraph V["Visual - compression"] E["Pick diagram type"] F["Mermaid V1 - ugly and fast"] G{"Obvious in 5 seconds?"} H["Refactor: labels order scope"] I["Kill clutter, keep signal ✂️"] J["Add light styling + hierarchy"] end subgraph S["Ship - learn loop"] K["Write post around diagram"] L{"Too long or too dense?"} M["Trim words, not meaning"] N["Render diagram + code as images 🖼️"] O["Post + pin code in comments 🔁"] Q["Comment signals: where readers stuck"] R["Patch diagram + post for V2"] end A --> B B --> C C --> D D -- High ROY --> E D -- Low ROY --> M E --> F F --> G G -- No --> H H --> F G -- Kinda --> I I --> F G -- Yes --> J J --> K K --> L L -- Yes --> M M --> K L -- No --> N N --> O O --> Q Q --> R R --> F A:::spark B:::core C:::core D:::gate E:::core F:::core G:::gate H:::risk I:::risk J:::core K:::core L:::gate M:::risk N:::publish O:::publish Q:::risk R:::core classDef spark fill:#fff4cc,stroke:#d6a700,color:#4a3b00,stroke-width:2px classDef core fill:#e8f3ff,stroke:#2b6cb0,color:#0b2a4a,stroke-width:1.5px classDef gate fill:#efe9ff,stroke:#6b46c1,color:#2a124d,stroke-width:1.5px classDef risk fill:#fff1f2,stroke:#c53030,color:#5a1010,stroke-width:1.5px classDef publish fill:#e9fbef,stroke:#2f855a,color:#0f3d25,stroke-width:2px linkStyle 0 stroke:#2b6cb0,stroke-width:2px,fill:none linkStyle 6 stroke:#c53030,stroke-width:2px,stroke-dasharray: 6 4,fill:none linkStyle 7 stroke:#c53030,stroke-width:2px,stroke-dasharray: 6 4,fill:none linkStyle 14 stroke:#2f855a,stroke-width:2px,fill:none

Replit V1

The builder’s eye. Code-first thinking, runtime honesty, builder pragmatism.

--- config: theme: neutral look: neo --- flowchart TD classDef spark fill:#c46a2c,stroke:#e6a03c,color:#0f172a classDef think fill:#1c3a34,stroke:#c46a2c,color:#e5e7eb classDef gate fill:#5b3a27,stroke:#e6a03c,color:#e5e7eb classDef revise fill:#676a2c,stroke:#e6a03c,color:#e5e7eb classDef ship fill:#111827,stroke:#c46a2c,color:#e5e7eb classDef tool fill:#2a2320,stroke:#e6a03c,color:#e6a03c A([💡 Spark: ROY insight]):::spark B[Define the claim\nWords → Structure → Understanding]:::think C{Is this diagram\nhonest — not happy-path?}:::gate D[Add loopbacks,\nforks, dead ends]:::revise E{ROY check:\nDid the words earn the visual?}:::gate F[Reframe in prose —\ndiagram isn't carrying its weight]:::revise G[Council of AIs:\nSame brief, independent models]:::think H{Does disagreement\nreveal structure?}:::gate I[Adjudicate + synthesize\nacross council outputs]:::think J[Ship: Post + Article v0.1\nProtoform release]:::ship K([🔧 Replit: Convert to\na runnable tool]):::tool A --> B --> C C -- Still lying --> D --> C C -- Honest --> E E -- Poor ROY --> F --> B E -- Strong ROY --> G --> H H -- Just noise --> G H -- Structure found --> I --> J --> K

Want to explore Mermaid diagrams yourself?

The diagrams above were built with Mermaid.js and rendered live on this page. To explore the syntax or build your own, Mermaid Chart is the place to start. That is a separate referral path from the diagram links above.